Tuesday, October 15, 2019

Educational Models


Educational Models

Democratic Schools

This educational model was very interesting to me because I had no idea that there was a school in Sudbury, MA.  My first thought was that I did not agree with it at all.  My issues were that the “staff members” and students were equals and that the teacher’s vote counts the same as a student’s.  How can this be productive without any adult leadership?  My other concern is that they spend their time doing whatever they want which can include reading, playing video games, cooking, and making art.  This sounds fun for the students but what are they learning?  Even as adults we wish we could do what we want, when we want but it is not realistic.  In my opinion, most people work best with some sort of schedule of responsibilities.  Although, this model is not one that I would consider for my children, there could be some benefits for students who require alternative forms of education.  Students who are not traditional learners or struggle to stay in school. 

Pedagogy of the Oppressed

I honestly struggled to understand this model, so I really do not have enough knowledge to comment on it. 

Flipped Classroom

Although I have not heard much about this model, I can only compare it to possibly being homeschooled.  I appreciated that it intentionally shifts instruction to a learner-centered model in which time in the classroom is used to explore topics in greater depth and create meaningful learning opportunities while students are initially introduced to new topics outside the classroom.  This could be useful to assists with all forms of learning such as oral, visual, listening, hands on, problem solving, etc.  but there seems to be a lot of technology used which concerns me.  My other concern is for students who are unable to organize and stay accountable for their work.  Will they fall behind?  In my opinion, increased screen time is not a benefit for students.  I would not consider this model for my children.

Montessori Education

This is a model that I am more familiar with and have toured a Montessori based preschool before.  There are many parts to this model that I respect such as uninterrupted blocks of work time and freedom within limits.  I like the philosophy that when children engage in psychological self-construction by means of interaction with their environments and that children who are at liberty to choose and act freely within an environment prepared according to her model would act spontaneously for optimal development.  I love Maria Montessori’s belief that education has a role to play in the development of world peace and created a curriculum based on Five Great Lessons.  Although this would not be my first choice for my child, I would not totally dismiss the idea of my child attending one.  My concerns with this model are the teacher’s role in the classroom and the stringency of materials used. 

Waldorf Education

I have heard of Waldorf schools but have not had any experience with them. 

The 7 benefits to there early childhood program sound very inviting and appropriate for young children. 

      1. Putting a heavy emphasis on speaking and listening early on

2    2. Continuous repetition to aid brain development

3    3. Writing is made fun

4    4. Allows the child to learn reading skills without forcing them to

5    5. Providing books to enhance vocabulary

6    6.  Doesn’t risk forcing pupils to read books too early

7    7. Teaches kids pronunciation without Phonics

I did some research online and did find several cons about the model which included their theory of not vaccinating children and possible issues with bullying and racist teachings.  I would like to believe that the Waldorf schools as well as all school systems are becoming more aware of bullying and racial issues.  I would most likely not have considered this model for my own children.

Glen Urquhart School

I appreciate that the curriculum for this model is enhanced by a campus designed to celebrate artistic expression, promote environmental awareness and appreciate and preserve the natural environment.  I also like the sense of community it creates by including people of diverse cultures, backgrounds and ethnicities along with its focus on community service.  I am not sure how I personally would have felt when they were more Christian based but like the idea of there being a spiritual piece.  I love the concept of so much of their learning taking place outside in nature and wish that this type of preschool was an option for my children when they were young. 



I think most forms of education models today are truly trying to focus on the whole child and are incorporating curriculum that includes respect, kindness, empathy, acceptance and personal integrity.  Technology (with limits) can benefit how we teach children and incorporate different teaching models into our curriculum.


1 comment:

  1. I agree that, as educators, we are really trying to "focus on whole child" and these methods are all trying to do this as well. Which is the best method probably depends on both the educator executing the idea, and the student.

    ReplyDelete